Free-text justifications for expert judgements

Free-text justifications for expert judgements

data_justifications

Format

A table with 5630 rows and 9 columns:

round

character string identifying whether the round was 1 (pre-discussion) or 2 (post-discussion)

paper_id

character string of the paper ids (25 papers total)

user_name

character string of anonymized IDs for each participant (25 participants included in this dataset)

question

character string for the question type, with five options: flushing_freetext, involved_binary, belief_binary, direct_replication, and comprehension

justification

character string with participant's free-text rationale for their responses

justification_id

character string with a unique ID for each row

vote_count

numeric of recorded votes (all 0 or 1)

vote_sum

numeric of summed vote counts(all 0 or 1)

group

character string of group IDs that contained the participants